It’s well known that the United States enjoys the dubious distinction of having the worst maternal morbidity and mortality rates among industrialized nations. Maternal mortality in this country increased by 14% from 2018 to 2020, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s National Center for Health Statistics.
But a current trend of engaging birth doulas — nonmedical guides offering continuous one-on-one physical and psychological support in the pre-, peri,- and postnatal periods — may be poised to brighten that dismal statistical landscape.
Recent research has shown that mothers matched with a doula are less likely to have a low-birthweight baby, less likely to experience a birth complication, and significantly more likely to initiate breastfeeding.
Doula services — even delivered digitally— are seen to lower healthcare costs, reduce cesarean sections, decrease maternal anxiety and depression, and improve communication between healthcare providers and low-income, racially/ethnically diverse pregnant women. Doulas can be especially helpful for mothers dealing with the psychological fallout of miscarriage or stillbirth. They can guide patients in the postpartum period, when problems can arise and when some mothers are lost to medical follow-up, and provide an ongoing source of patient information for the ob/gyn.
“Research has shown that in addition to better outcomes, doula care can shorten labor time and increase patient satisfaction,” said ob/gyn Layan Alrahmani, MD, in an interview. A maternal-fetal medicine specialist with a focus on high-risk pregnancies among low-income women at Loyola Medicine in Maywood, Illinois, Alrahmani welcomes doulas to her patients’ antenatal visits.
“Many of my patients who are looking to avoid an epidural will work with a labor doula, in order to stay home as long as possible and to have one-on-one coaching through the pain as things progress,” said Susan Rothenberg, MD, an assistant professor of obstetrics, gynecology, and reproductive science at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai and an ob/gyn at Mount Sinai Downtown Union Square in New York City. She added, “When a woman’s partner is squeamish or potentially unavailable, a labor doula can be a great option.”
Another ob/gyn who enthusiastically embraces doula care is L. Joy Baker, MD, who practices in LaGrange, Georgia, and is affiliated with Wellstar West Georgia Medical Center. “I love it when my patients have a doula. A doula answers a patient’s questions throughout the pregnancy and amplifies the mother’s voice in the medical system and the clinical setting,” Baker told Medscape Medical News.
“They provide important details on patients’ food, housing, and transportation status when the mothers themselves would not bring those up in a short appointment with their doctors,” she said. Baker called for more recognition of their merit, especially for first-time and high-risk moms.
Efua B. Leke, MD, MPH, an assistant professor at Baylor College of Medicine and chief of obstetrics at Ben Taub Hospital in Houston, Texas, also believes a major benefit of doulas is improved flow of information. ” We know that having doulas participate in maternal care can ease communication between pregnant and parturient mothers and their clinical team,” Leke said. “This is especially important for under-resourced pregnant women for whom morbidity tends to be disparately higher.”
Doulas can also take pressure off embattled ob/gyn clinical staff. “Our volume of patients is huge, so we have to keep appointments brief,” Baker said. “The US is currently 8000 ob/gyns short, and to make matters worse, we’re seeing more and more obstetrical care deserts.”
Still largely underutilized, doula care is seen by its proponents as important in light of the drastic shortage of ob/gyns and the shrinking presence of maternity care in many US counties.
According to a recent March of Dimes report, access to maternity care is waning, with more than 35% of US counties offering no community obstetrical care and 52% providing no maternity care in local hospitals. That translates to long distances and extended travel time for mothers seeking care.
Growth Remains SlowAlthough many believe doulas could become part of the solution to the lack of access to maternity care, their acceptance seems to be slow growing. In a 2012 national survey by Declercq and associates, about 6% of mothers used a doula during childbirth, up from 3% in a 2006 national survey. Of those who were familiar with but lacking doula care, just 27% would have chosen to have this service.
“I’d estimate that doulas are still involved in only about 6%-8% of births,” said Shaconna Haley, MA, a certified holistic doula and doula trainer in Atlanta, Georgia.
And are there enough practicing doulas in the US to put a dent in the current shortfall in pregnancy care? Although no reliable estimate of their numbers exists, a centralized online doula registration service listed 9000 registered practitioners in 2018. Contrast that with the approximately 3.6 million live births in 2023.
Potential for Friction?Although generally seen as benign and helpful, the presence of a doula can add another layer of people for hard-pressed medical staff to deal with. Can their attendance occasionally lead to an adversarial encounter? Yes, said Baker, especially in the case of assertive questioning or suggestions directed at medical staff. “There can be some mistrust on the part of clinicians when nonmedical persons start raising concerns and asking questions. Staff can get a little prickly at this.”
In the view of Melissa A. Simon, MD, MPH, a professor of obstetrics and gynecology, preventive medicine, and medical social sciences at Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine in Chicago, Illinois, simple, preventable communication breakdown is often the cause of occasional antagonism. “As in all team care approaches, it’s helpful to have upfront conversations with the birthing person, the doula, and any care team members or support people who will be present in the birthing room. These conversations should be about expectations.”
According to Haley, “As long as the focus stays firmly on the client/patient and not on the other team members, there should be no friction. Medical staff should be aware there will be a doula in attendance and ideally there should be a collaborative team and plan in place before the birth.”
In Leke’s experience, doulas do not hinder the medical team as long as clinical roles are well clarified and the patient is engaged in her care plan. “Friction can occur when doulas are functioning outside of their scope of practice, such as speaking to the healthcare team on behalf of the mother instead empowering the mother to speak up herself,” she said. “Or, when the healthcare team doesn’t understand the doula’s scope of practice or recognize the doula as a member of the team.”
Added Rothenberg, “I’ve occasionally run into doulas who imagine I have an ulterior motive when making recommendations to patients when that’s completely untrue. It’s common for women to decide to become doulas because they didn’t feel listened to during their own birthing experience, and for a few of them, it’s hard to not project that onto their clients’ labor situations, creating conflict where it doesn’t need to exist.”
Barriers and Challenges Unfortunately, the barriers of cost and access remain high for pregnant and birthing mothers from lower socioeconomic echelons who have no or limited insurance. “There also are very few multilingual doulas or doulas from diverse racial-ethnic backgrounds and identities,” Simon pointed out.
Yet by all indications, Medicaid members who receive doula services experience positive maternal outcomes, even those at higher risk for pregnancy complications.
As for Medicaid coverage of doula services, in a recent Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services report, just 11 state Medicaid programs were reimbursing doula services, whereas an additional five were in the process of implementing reimbursement.
Doula care is not covered by all private insurance plans either, Simon said. “Although there are maternity care bundles with payment models that help integrate doula care, and there are ways to use your flexible spending account to cover it.”
Some hospitals may undertake independent initiatives. Baker’s center is partnering with the March of Dimes to offer antenatal and peripartum doula support for underresourced mothers.
But for now, doula services are largely limited to middle- and high-income women able to afford the associated out-of-pocket costs. These mothers are disproportionately White, and the doulas serving them tend to be of the same race and socioeconomic class.
The FutureSimon foresees an optimal scenario in which a team of doulas works with all birthing persons on a hospital labor floor as well as with a team of clinicians. “It takes a true team approach to ensure an optimal birthing experience and optimal birth outcomes,” she said.
Despite the many challenges ahead, doulas will probably become a permanent fixture in pregnancy, birth, and postpartum care, said Baker. “Doula care is going to be a game changer, and obstetricians welcome doulas to the obstetrical care team.”
Alrahmani, Baker, Haley, Leke, Rothenberg, and Simon declared no conflicts of interest relevant to their comments.
Diana Swift is a medical journalist based in Toronto, Canada.
Source : Medscape